The 2019 LSU Tigers are often considered to be the greatest college football team in history. They went 15-0 while destroying teams like Oklahoma and Clemson, and ended up winning the CFP (College Football Playoff) National Championship. Their team consisted of superstars such as Heisman winner Joe Burrow, Justin Jefferson, Derek Stingley Jr., Ja’marr Chase, and many more.
On the other hand, the 2024 Carolina Panthers are considered to be one of the worst teams in the NFL. They went 2-15 last year, and are already off to a 1-4 start. Their team is headlined by players who were drafted in the first round of the NFL draft and projected to be NFL stars but have not yet lived up to the expectations. Some of these players include Jaycee Horn, Bryce Young, and Dionte Johnson. While they may not have the superstardom of the 2019 LSU team, it is important to remember that the Panthers are made up of NFL players, who are significantly better than college players.
While comparing these two teams, there are several factors that need to be considered.
While both teams have several talented players, the level of talent in the NFL is generally higher than that in college football. The NFL is composed of the best college players, and the draft system and free agency allow teams to acquire top-tier talent. While the Panthers may seem insignificant compared to the rest of the NFL, it is still important to remember that every NFL team is made up of the best college players, as only those players get drafted using a limited number of picks.
The level of coaching can also play a significant role in the outcome of any sports game. Both LSU and the Panthers have had successful coaching staffs, but the NFL’s level of coaching is often considered to be at a high level. Usually, the best college coaches get promoted up to the NFL, one example being Jim Harbaugh, who was the coach for the 2024 Michigan Wolverines won the National Championship. Seeing this, the Los Angeles Chargers decided to hire him to be the coach of their team.
NFL players have more experience playing at a higher level than college players. They are bigger, stronger, faster, and overall better athletes. This experience could give the Panthers a significant advantage in terms of execution and decision-making.
I talked to Mr. Voelker, who is an avid Chiefs fan and self-proclaimed NFL expert, and this is what he had to say when asked ”whether the 2019 LSU Tigers could beat the 2024 Carolina Panthers”. “No, I don’t think so. I know LSU had good offensive players, but I’m forgetting their defensive pieces. The offense line for the Panthers is really, really good, and with Bryce Young starting for the Panthers, LSU would give them a run for their money. But with Andy Dalton as quarterback, he’s too smart and I think the Panthers would beat LSU. There’s just way too much talent on the offensive line.”
It is difficult to say whether the 2019 LSU Tigers could beat the 2024 Carolina Panthers, but we can use several factors to predict the outcome. To be an NFL player, you have to have a certain level of skills, size, and speed, attributes that are not always needed at the collegiate level. As a result of all these factors, I predict that the Carolina Panthers will beat the LSU Tigers. Though the Tigers have many stars, the Carolina Panthers are composed of bigger and better athletes with more experience, hence they would win.
